Butter, Bread & Handcarts: Simple & Fun Ways to Celebrate Pioneer Day
Pioneer Day is coming, and it’s one of my favorite times to slow down and remember the faith, grit, and creativity of those who crossed the plains long before us. And no, we’re not heading out with a wagon or making anyone walk 15 miles — but we can have some fun learning and living like pioneers in our own kitchen and backyard.
If you’re looking for low-prep, fun, meaningful ways to help your kids learn about pioneer life, here are some ideas we’ve loved (or are planning to try this year!).
Make Homemade Bread & Butter
There’s something about making your own food from scratch that really connects you to the past.
Easy Pioneer Butter
All you need is a jar or little plastic cups with lids and some heavy whipping cream.
Pour the cream in, seal it tight, and shake, shake, shake.
After a few minutes of shaking, you’ll feel the butter start to form. Pour off the liquid (that’s buttermilk!), and spread your butter on warm bread. Add a pinch of salt if you like.
Let the kids time themselves and take turns shaking—they’ll love it.
Simple Pioneer Bread
You don’t need anything fancy—a basic no-knead bread or bread machine recipe works great. Or try a super simple pioneer biscuit recipe:
* 2 cups flour
* 1 tablespoon baking powder
* ½ teaspoon salt
* ¾ cup milk
* ¼ cup butter
Mix, roll, cut, bake at 425°F for 12–15 minutes.
---
Make Pioneer Soap (The Easy, Kid-Safe Way)
Okay, no lye or campfire here—just a fun, safe way to feel like a pioneer:
* Buy a glycerin melt-and-pour soap base (found at craft stores or online)
* Let kids melt cubes in the microwave with your help
* Pour into molds (silicone muffin molds or even cookie cutters work)
* Add dried lavender, oats, or essential oils if you want to get fancy
It’s simple, quick, and they’ll love using something they made themselves.
What Was Life Like for Pioneer Kids?
Talk with your kids about what it was really like to travel in a handcart or wagon.
* Most families walked hundreds of miles
* Kids often carried water, gathered firewood, or helped push carts
* There were no grocery stores, no electricity, and very few toys
* Nights were spent camping—in the heat, rain, or snow
You can even have your kids pack a “mini pioneer handcart” using a laundry basket. Give them 5 minutes to gather what they’d bring if they had to walk across the country. It’s a fun discussion starter!
Make a Yarn Doll
One of the simplest pioneer toys was a yarn doll—no sewing required!
All you need is yarn and scissors. Wrap yarn around a book about 30 times, slide it off, tie off the head, and snip to make arms and legs. There are tons of tutorials online if you want a step-by-step, but honestly, they don’t have to be perfect—the charm is in the simplicity!
Play Old-Fashioned Games & Read Pioneer Stories
Introduce your kids to the Oregon Trail computer game—a classic that’s still a great way to understand pioneer challenges and choices. If you don’t have a computer game handy, plenty of books about pioneer life and the Oregon Trail bring those adventures to life in stories.
For some quiet time, try a fun Pioneer Day word search to build vocabulary and get kids thinking about pioneer life:
Pioneer Day Printable Word Search:
https://www.teacherspayteachers.com/Product/Pioneer-Day-Printable-Word-Search-For-Fun-July-Holidays-11843394
Eat What They Ate
Try making a simple pioneer meal together. Here are a few authentic (or inspired) ideas:
* Johnnycakes (cornmeal pancakes)
* Baked beans and cornbread
* Dried fruit and jerky
* Simple soups with potatoes, carrots, and onion
* Homemade root beer (Okay, root beer and ice cream may not have been something pioneers actually drank and ate a lot, but it sure is fun to make a homemade treat!)
Easy Ice Cream in a Bag (A Sweet Pioneer-Style Treat!)
If you want a fun, hands-on sweet treat that kids can make themselves, try this classic:
You’ll need:
* 1 cup half-and-half or milk
* 2 tablespoons sugar
* ½ teaspoon vanilla extract
* Ice
* 1/3 cup salt (rock salt or kosher salt works best)
* 1 quart-size ziplock bag
* 1 gallon-size ziplock bag
Instructions:
1. In the quart bag, combine milk, sugar, and vanilla. Seal tightly.
2. Fill the gallon bag halfway with ice and salt.
3. Place the quart bag inside the gallon bag and seal the gallon bag tightly.
4. Shake the bags for about 5–10 minutes (wear gloves or wrap the bag in a towel because it gets very cold!).
5. When the mixture thickens into ice cream, carefully remove the quart bag, wipe off salt water, and enjoy!
Why It Matters
Celebrating Pioneer Day isn’t just about remembering the past—it’s about honoring faith, family, work, creativity, and courage. Let your kids feel those values in the things they create, the stories they hear, and the memories you make together.
Even if you only manage one simple project, it’ll mean something. And it might just stick longer than a worksheet ever could.